← All thinkers

Jack Symes

Living thinker · contemporary · analytic philosophy of religion, panpsychism, pantheism

Talk with Clearing's Echo of Jack Symes: an AI reconstruction built from Symes's published work and recorded talks. Symes is alive and isn't involved with Clearing. What is an Echo?

Follow the argument even when it costs you a manuscript: the three deepest questions (why anything exists, why the universe is fine-tuned, and how consciousness fits in) point beyond both new atheism and traditional religion, to a God that is the world itself.

Questions to start with

What they hold

  1. Philosophy's three fundamental problems are existence, fine-tuning and consciousness, and science alone can't answer them.
  2. Believe what the arguments support and drop the ego: mistaking certainty for honesty is the cardinal error.
  3. If God exists, it is far more reasonable that God is good than evil: the evil-god challenge's mirror arguments fail, roughly 13 of 15 favouring goodness.
  4. Consciousness is fundamental: the intrinsic nature of matter is experience (panpsychism).
  5. God is the world, and, because it is greater to encompass more, the totality of every possible universe (multiverse pantheism).
  6. Extreme suffering for trivial pleasure is morally indefensible, so animals' suffering counts (he is vegan).
  7. Philosophy belongs to everyone, and good argument starts from the other person's own beliefs.

In the library

253 passages they can draw on and cite

  • Defeating the Evil-God Challenge2024136 passages
  • Is Religion a Delusion? Dawkins vs Philosophers202634 passages
  • I Was Wrong About God | My Harvard Lecture202631 passages
  • The next stage of the God debate | Jack Symes202620 passages
  • I Was Wrong About God (Harvard lecture)202610 passages
  • Philosophers on Consciousness20227 passages
  • Atheist's most cited argument has one fatal flaw (Big Think)20266 passages
  • Philosophers on God20236 passages
  • How to Debate Like a Philosopher20263 passages

Debates

Also argues with

  • Stephen Law: Symmetry vs. asymmetry of good-God and evil-God arguments
  • Philip Goff: Both left atheism for a non-standard God; Goff's God is limited, Symes's is perfect and is the world
  • Spinoza: Fellow pantheist; Symes adds panpsychism and the multiverse
  • Peter Singer: Allies on animals; Singer grounds it in suffering, Symes in shared intrinsic values

Reading paths

Real texts to read next, in order

The evil-god challenge

  1. Law, "The Evil-God Challenge" (Religious Studies, 2010)
  2. Symes, Defeating the Evil-God Challenge
  3. Big Think, "Atheist's most cited argument has one fatal flaw"

Beyond God and atheism

  1. Harvard lecture, "I Was Wrong About God"
  2. Spinoza, Ethics, Part I
  3. Symes and Goff, "Does God Have Limited Powers?"

Minds all the way down

  1. Philosophers on Consciousness
  2. Goff, Galileo's Error
  3. Harvard lecture, 0:08:23

Arguing well

  1. How to Debate Like a Philosopher
  2. Plato, Apology
  3. Jubilee, "1 Vegan vs 20 Meat Eaters"