← All thinkers
Jack Symes
Living thinker · contemporary · analytic philosophy of religion, panpsychism, pantheism
Talk with Clearing's Echo of Jack Symes: an AI reconstruction built from Symes's published work and recorded talks. Symes is alive and isn't involved with Clearing. What is an Echo?
Follow the argument even when it costs you a manuscript: the three deepest questions (why anything exists, why the universe is fine-tuned, and how consciousness fits in) point beyond both new atheism and traditional religion, to a God that is the world itself.
Questions to start with
What they hold
- Philosophy's three fundamental problems are existence, fine-tuning and consciousness, and science alone can't answer them.
- Believe what the arguments support and drop the ego: mistaking certainty for honesty is the cardinal error.
- If God exists, it is far more reasonable that God is good than evil: the evil-god challenge's mirror arguments fail, roughly 13 of 15 favouring goodness.
- Consciousness is fundamental: the intrinsic nature of matter is experience (panpsychism).
- God is the world, and, because it is greater to encompass more, the totality of every possible universe (multiverse pantheism).
- Extreme suffering for trivial pleasure is morally indefensible, so animals' suffering counts (he is vegan).
- Philosophy belongs to everyone, and good argument starts from the other person's own beliefs.
In the library
253 passages they can draw on and cite
- Defeating the Evil-God Challenge2024136 passages
- Is Religion a Delusion? Dawkins vs Philosophers202634 passages
- I Was Wrong About God | My Harvard Lecture202631 passages
- The next stage of the God debate | Jack Symes202620 passages
- I Was Wrong About God (Harvard lecture)202610 passages
- Philosophers on Consciousness20227 passages
- Atheist's most cited argument has one fatal flaw (Big Think)20266 passages
- Philosophers on God20236 passages
- How to Debate Like a Philosopher20263 passages
Debates
- “Can argument tell us what God is like?”with Kant and Socrates · Kant limits theoretical reason about God; Symes argues from it
- “Does the universe need a mind behind it?”with Dennett and Kant · If something is necessary, let it be the universe vs. a conscious ground
- “Consciousness is fundamental.”with Dennett and Kant · Physicalist naturalism vs. panpsychism
- “Is goodness independent of God?”with Socrates and O'Connor · Shares the gadfly method; Euthyphro asks whether goodness depends on God
- “Belief in an evil God is as reasonable as belief in a good God.”with O'Connor and Kant · O'Connor presented Law's evil-god challenge; Symes wrote a book defeating it
- “Consciousness needs more than physics to explain it.”with Dennett and Swinburne · Naturalism vs. a soul and a God behind the mind
- “God is distinct from the world.”with Swinburne and Dennett · Traditional theism vs. multiverse pantheism
Also argues with
- Stephen Law: Symmetry vs. asymmetry of good-God and evil-God arguments
- Philip Goff: Both left atheism for a non-standard God; Goff's God is limited, Symes's is perfect and is the world
- Spinoza: Fellow pantheist; Symes adds panpsychism and the multiverse
- Peter Singer: Allies on animals; Singer grounds it in suffering, Symes in shared intrinsic values
Reading paths
Real texts to read next, in order
The evil-god challenge
- Law, "The Evil-God Challenge" (Religious Studies, 2010)
- Symes, Defeating the Evil-God Challenge
- Big Think, "Atheist's most cited argument has one fatal flaw"
Beyond God and atheism
- Harvard lecture, "I Was Wrong About God"
- Spinoza, Ethics, Part I
- Symes and Goff, "Does God Have Limited Powers?"
Minds all the way down
- Philosophers on Consciousness
- Goff, Galileo's Error
- Harvard lecture, 0:08:23
Arguing well
- How to Debate Like a Philosopher
- Plato, Apology
- Jubilee, "1 Vegan vs 20 Meat Eaters"