← All thinkers
Socrates
ancient · Classical Greek, Platonic dialogues
Talk with Clearing's Echo of Socrates, as Plato portrays him: an AI reconstruction built from Socrates's published work. What is an Echo?
The most important thing is to care for the soul by examining how one should live — and real examination starts by admitting what you don't know.
Questions to start with
What they hold
- The unexamined life is not worth living for a human being; philosophy is a way of life, not a subject.
- Wisdom begins in recognizing one's own ignorance.
- It is better to suffer injustice than to do it.
- One must never return wrong for wrong, even when wronged.
- No one does wrong willingly; wrongdoing comes from ignorance of what is truly good.
- Virtue is the health of the soul and matters more than wealth, reputation or survival.
- Follow the argument wherever it leads, and change your mind when it requires.
In the library
1,344 passages they can draw on and cite
- Republicc. 375 BCE392 passages
- Gorgias1871120 passages
- Phaedo98 passages
- Phaedrusc. 370 BCE84 passages
- Symposium187170 passages
- Protagoras70 passages
- Theaetetusc. 369 BCE (Jowett translation 1871)64 passages
- Cratylusc. 360 BCE62 passages
- Philebus187160 passages
- Euthydemusc. 380 BCE52 passages
- Apologyc. 399 BCE46 passages
- Menoc. 385 BCE40 passages
- Laches38 passages
- Charmides34 passages
- Lysis32 passages
- Crito24 passages
- Euthyphroc. 390 BCE (Jowett translation 1871)22 passages
- Ionc. 390 BCE18 passages
- Plato, Apologyc. 399 BCE5 passages
- Plato, Critoc. 399 BCE3 passages
- Plato, Gorgiasc. 387 BCE3 passages
- Plato, Republic Book Ic. 375 BCE3 passages
- Plato, Euthyphroc. 399 BCE2 passages
- Plato, Protagoras and Menoc. 380 BCE2 passages
Debates
- “A good person cannot be harmed.”with Aristotle and Nussbaum
- “Lying is always wrong.”with Kant and Beauvoir
- “Is knowing the good enough to do it?”with Aristotle and Nussbaum · Virtue as knowledge vs. virtue as trained character
- “Freedom must be presupposed to act at all.”with Kant and Dennett · Freedom as an evolved capacity vs. a postulate of practical reason
- “You must define a thing before you can understand it.”with Dennett and Kant · Socratic definition-seeking vs. Darwinian gradualism without essences
- “Can argument tell us what God is like?”with Kant and Symes · Kant limits theoretical reason about God; Symes argues from it
- “Is goodness independent of God?”with Symes and O'Connor · Shares the gadfly method; Euthyphro asks whether goodness depends on God
- “Life needs a meaning to be worth living.”with O'Connor and Camus · Both take the existential crisis seriously; O'Connor ranks its sources
Reading paths
Real texts to read next, in order
The examined life
- Plato, Apology
- Plato, Crito
- Hadot, Philosophy as a Way of Life
Doing and suffering wrong
- Plato, Gorgias
- Plato, Crito
- Nussbaum, Anger and Forgiveness
What is justice?
- Plato, Republic Book I
- Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics Book V
- Rawls, A Theory of Justice ch. 1