← All thinkers
Robert M. Sapolsky
Living thinker · contemporary · neuroscience, primatology, hard incompatibilism
Talk with Clearing's Echo of Robert M. Sapolsky: an AI reconstruction built from Sapolsky's published work and recorded talks. Sapolsky is alive and isn't involved with Clearing. What is an Echo?
We have no free will at all: every behaviour is the product of biology and environment over which we had no control, from the second before to the millions of years before, so blame and praise rest on a mistake.
Questions to start with
What they hold
- There is no free will: behaviour is fully caused by prior events, a turtles-all-the-way-down chain (Determined, ch. 1 and "Interlude").
- The causes stretch across all timescales: seconds, minutes, adolescence, childhood, the womb, genes, culture, evolution ("Where Does Intent Come From?").
- Even grit and willpower are products of biology and circumstance, not free choices ("Willing Willpower: The Myth of Grit").
- Chaos, emergent complexity and quantum indeterminacy don't rescue free will; unpredictability or randomness isn't control ("Is Your Free Will Random?").
- Compatibilism keeps a "myth" of partial free will: not here and now but somewhere; that move fails.
- Without free will, retribution is unjustified; society may still restrain dangerous people (a quarantine model) without blaming them ("The Joy of Punishment").
- Accepting this is possible without chaos; we have changed such beliefs before (epilepsy is no longer witchcraft) ("Will We Run Amok?", "We Really Have Done This Before").
In the library
296 passages they can draw on and cite
- Determined2023254 passages
- "Why Zebras Don't Get Ulcers: Stress and Health" by Dr. Robert Sapolsky201727 passages
- Determined: Life without Free Will with Robert Sapolsky202415 passages
Debates
- “Morality requires freedom.”with Kant and Nussbaum · Freedom as a presupposition of morality vs. none at all
- “Anger at wrongdoers is never deserved.”with Nussbaum and Kant · Both reject retribution; she keeps responsibility, he doesn't
- “We can master our passions by will.”with Seneca and Nussbaum · Stoic self-mastery vs. the myth of grit
- “Free will is an illusion.”with Dennett and Kant · No free will vs. compatibilist free will worth wanting
- “Without free will, blame makes no sense.”with O'Connor and Nussbaum · Allies against free will; differ on what follows for morality
Reading paths
Real texts to read next, in order
No free will
- Sapolsky, Determined, "Turtles All the Way Down"
- "Where Does Intent Come From?"
- Dennett, Freedom Evolves, ch. 2
Blame and punishment
- Sapolsky, "The Joy of Punishment"
- Nussbaum, Anger and Forgiveness, ch. 6
- Seneca, On Anger, Book II
Randomness and the mind
- Sapolsky, "Is Your Free Will Random?"
- O'Connor, "Why Free Will Doesn't Exist"