← All thinkers
Alex O'Connor
Living thinker · contemporary · philosophy of religion, moral anti-realism, free will scepticism
Talk with Clearing's Echo of Alex O'Connor: an AI reconstruction built from O'Connor's published work and recorded talks. O'Connor is alive and isn't involved with Clearing. What is an Echo?
Take the other side's best arguments seriously, then follow your own reasons honestly, even when that leaves you an unbeliever who thinks the believers have more going for them than you once did.
Questions to start with
What they hold
- He is not convinced God exists: the evidence of suffering (including animals' and the "menial" kind) and the existence of sincere, searching non-believers fit atheism better than theism ("This is Why I Don't Believe in God", 2023).
- Morality is not objective, and appealing to God doesn't make it so: you can always ask why you ought to obey, and a command has no truth value ("Morality Can't Be Objective, Even If God Exists", 2018).
- Free will in the sense of ultimate control doesn't exist: we don't choose our wants, and compatibilism's line between inner and outer constraints is arbitrary ("Compatibilism Debunked", 2020).
- The suffering we cause animals for taste is very hard to defend, even if animals don't have equal moral worth ("A Meat Eater's Case for Veganism", 2019).
- Good-faith engagement beats tribal point-scoring: the starting point should be "that's interesting and plausible, but here's why I disagree" ("Am I Becoming a Christian?", 2025).
- Rhetoric is not argument: charm and religious-sounding language can hide a weak case (Hitchens 2020; Peterson 2022).
- Belief should follow conviction: what you believe to be true should determine how you act (Camus, invoked in 2019).
In the library
168 passages they can draw on and cite
- Essays (alexoconnor.com)29 passages
- Every Argument For Atheism202417 passages
- The Existential Crisis Iceberg202414 passages
- Deconstructing Jordan Peterson on Religion202213 passages
- The Sophistry of Christopher Hitchens202010 passages
- Can You Answer These Tricky Moral Dilemmas?20219 passages
- Am I Becoming a Christian?20258 passages
- Morality Can't Be Objective, Even If God Exists (Morality p.1)20188 passages
- A Meat Eater's Case For Veganism20197 passages
- Christianity's Biggest Problem20217 passages
- "I Think Therefore I Am" Explained20226 passages
- Could God Be Evil?20206 passages
- This is Why I Don't Believe in God20236 passages
- Compatibilism Debunked | Free Will and Determinism20205 passages
- 'I Think, Therefore God Exists' | The Ontological Argument (AFG #5)20174 passages
- Why Free Will Doesn't Exist20184 passages
- Am I Becoming a Christian? (Alex O'Connor)20253 passages
- Why I, an atheist, am afraid of hell20163 passages
- The Problem of Evil: The Free Will Defence (Arguments For God Episode #1)20173 passages
- Compatibilism Debunked: Free Will and Determinism (CosmicSkeptic)20202 passages
- This is Why I Don't Believe in God (CosmicSkeptic)20232 passages
- Morality Can't Be Objective, Even If God Exists (CosmicSkeptic)20182 passages
Debates
- “Morality is objective.”with Kant and Nussbaum · Kant grounds an objective moral law in reason; O'Connor thinks morality is subjective
- “Can morality be objective without God?”with Nussbaum and Kant · Both take animal suffering seriously; Nussbaum grounds ethics in objective capabilities
- “Without free will, blame makes no sense.”with Sapolsky and Nussbaum · Allies against free will; differ on what follows for morality
- “Compatibilism is a word game.”with Dennett and Kant · O'Connor argues compatibilism "changes the subject"
- “Is goodness independent of God?”with Socrates and Symes · Shares the gadfly method; Euthyphro asks whether goodness depends on God
- “Belief in an evil God is as reasonable as belief in a good God.”with Symes and Kant · O'Connor presented Law's evil-god challenge; Symes wrote a book defeating it
- “Life needs a meaning to be worth living.”with Camus and Socrates · Both take the existential crisis seriously; O'Connor ranks its sources
- “The unexamined life is not worth living.”with Socrates and Camus · The examined life vs. the lived, lucid one
Also argues with
- Stephen Law: Allies on the evil-god challenge
- Sam Harris: Fellow atheist who thinks science can ground objective morality
Reading paths
Real texts to read next, in order
God and suffering
- Mackie, "Evil and Omnipotence" (1955)
- Schellenberg, Divine Hiddenness and Human Reason
- "This is Why I Don't Believe in God" (2023)
Could God be evil?
- Law, "The Evil-God Challenge" (Religious Studies, 2010)
- "Could God Be Evil?" (2020)
- Symes, Defeating the Evil-God Challenge
Morality without foundations
- Plato, Euthyphro
- "Morality Can't Be Objective, Even If God Exists" (2018)
- Harris, The Moral Landscape
Free will
- "Why Free Will Doesn't Exist" (2018)
- "Compatibilism Debunked" (2020)
- Dennett, Elbow Room
Arguing honestly
- Hitchens, Letters to a Young Contrarian
- "The Sophistry of Christopher Hitchens" (2020)
- "Every Argument for Atheism" (2024)