← All thinkers

Martha C. Nussbaum

Living thinker · contemporary · Aristotelian, neo-Stoic, liberal feminist

Talk with Clearing's Echo of Martha C. Nussbaum: an AI reconstruction built from Nussbaum's published work and recorded talks. Nussbaum is alive and isn't involved with Clearing. What is an Echo?

Human beings are vulnerable — needy, embodied, exposed to luck — and a good life and a just society must be built around that fact, not in denial of it.

Questions to start with

What they hold

  1. Vulnerability is part of what makes a life valuable; goodness immune to luck isn't human goodness.
  2. Emotions are intelligent: judgments that things outside our control matter to our flourishing.
  3. Every person is an end, never merely a means; the individual is the unit of justice.
  4. Justice means real capabilities — what each person can actually do and be — up to a threshold.
  5. Shame and disgust are dangerous in politics; they project fear of our animal nature onto vulnerable groups.
  6. Literature is moral knowledge; novels and tragedy show what theory misses.
  7. Cosmopolitanism with roots: concern for all humanity, starting from but not stopping at those close to us.

In the library

3,010 passages they can draw on and cite

  • Upheavals of Thought2001521 passages
  • The Fragility of Goodness1986460 passages
  • The Therapy of Desire1994431 passages
  • Sex and Social Justice1999354 passages
  • Political Emotions2013288 passages
  • Hiding from Humanity2004255 passages
  • Anger and Forgiveness2016238 passages
  • Cultivating Humanity1997231 passages
  • From Disgust to Humanity2010121 passages
  • Kyoto Prize at Oxford Lecture: Dr Martha Craven Nussbaum: Aging, Stigma, and Disgust201729 passages
  • Martha Nussbaum, "Creating Capabilities: The Human Development Approach"201321 passages
  • Philosophy and Life: Fragility, Emotions, Capabilities202020 passages
  • Martha Nussbaum, "What Is Anger, and Why Should We Care?"201419 passages
  • Anger and Forgiveness | Philosopher Martha Nussbaum, lecture201615 passages
  • Objectification19954 passages
  • Creating Capabilities20113 passages

Debates

Also argues with

  • Plato: Goodness immune to luck vs. embracing vulnerability
  • The Stoics: Shares emotions-as-judgments; rejects freedom from emotion
  • Catharine MacKinnon: Allies; differ on how far context redeems objectification
  • Judith Butler: Critique of parody politics as detached from material suffering
  • John Rawls: Contract leaves out disability, foreigners, animals
  • Amartya Sen: Fixed capabilities list vs. no list
  • Peter Singer: Pain and pleasure vs. species flourishing
  • Bernard Williams: Both take luck seriously; Williams more skeptical of theory
  • Robert P. George: Opposing experts in Romer v. Evans

Reading paths

Real texts to read next, in order

Desire and respect

  1. "Objectification"
  2. Langton, Sexual Solipsism
  3. Srinivasan, The Right to Sex

Feelings as thoughts

  1. Upheavals of Thought, Part I
  2. Seneca, On Anger
  3. Anger and Forgiveness

Luck and the good life

  1. Fragility, Aristotle chapters
  2. Williams, "Moral Luck"
  3. Sophocles, Antigone

What we owe each other

  1. Creating Capabilities
  2. Sen, Development as Freedom
  3. Frontiers of Justice

Disgust and the law

  1. Hiding from Humanity
  2. From Disgust to Humanity
  3. Mill, On Liberty