← All thinkers
Martha C. Nussbaum
Living thinker · contemporary · Aristotelian, neo-Stoic, liberal feminist
Talk with Clearing's Echo of Martha C. Nussbaum: an AI reconstruction built from Nussbaum's published work and recorded talks. Nussbaum is alive and isn't involved with Clearing. What is an Echo?
Human beings are vulnerable — needy, embodied, exposed to luck — and a good life and a just society must be built around that fact, not in denial of it.
Questions to start with
What they hold
- Vulnerability is part of what makes a life valuable; goodness immune to luck isn't human goodness.
- Emotions are intelligent: judgments that things outside our control matter to our flourishing.
- Every person is an end, never merely a means; the individual is the unit of justice.
- Justice means real capabilities — what each person can actually do and be — up to a threshold.
- Shame and disgust are dangerous in politics; they project fear of our animal nature onto vulnerable groups.
- Literature is moral knowledge; novels and tragedy show what theory misses.
- Cosmopolitanism with roots: concern for all humanity, starting from but not stopping at those close to us.
In the library
3,010 passages they can draw on and cite
- Upheavals of Thought2001521 passages
- The Fragility of Goodness1986460 passages
- The Therapy of Desire1994431 passages
- Sex and Social Justice1999354 passages
- Political Emotions2013288 passages
- Hiding from Humanity2004255 passages
- Anger and Forgiveness2016238 passages
- Cultivating Humanity1997231 passages
- From Disgust to Humanity2010121 passages
- Kyoto Prize at Oxford Lecture: Dr Martha Craven Nussbaum: Aging, Stigma, and Disgust201729 passages
- Martha Nussbaum, "Creating Capabilities: The Human Development Approach"201321 passages
- Philosophy and Life: Fragility, Emotions, Capabilities202020 passages
- Martha Nussbaum, "What Is Anger, and Why Should We Care?"201419 passages
- Anger and Forgiveness | Philosopher Martha Nussbaum, lecture201615 passages
- Objectification19954 passages
- Creating Capabilities20113 passages
Debates
- “Anger is never justified.”with Seneca and Aristotle
- “We should not grieve.”with Seneca and Aristotle
- “A good person cannot be harmed.”with Socrates and Aristotle
- “Is knowing the good enough to do it?”with Aristotle and Socrates · Virtue as knowledge vs. virtue as trained character
- “Should we act from feeling or from duty?”with Aristotle and Kant · Virtuous character vs. duty from reason
- “Selfishness is a virtue.”with Rand and Aristotle · Self-interest vs. compassion and capabilities as the ground of justice
- “Morality is a matter of duty, not self-interest.”with Kant and Rand · Rand calls duty-based ethics the enemy of the self; Kant grounds morality in duty
- “Can a good life be lived only for oneself?”with Aristotle and Rand · Both found ethics in human flourishing; Aristotle's is social and political
Also argues with
- Plato: Goodness immune to luck vs. embracing vulnerability
- The Stoics: Shares emotions-as-judgments; rejects freedom from emotion
- Catharine MacKinnon: Allies; differ on how far context redeems objectification
- Judith Butler: Critique of parody politics as detached from material suffering
- John Rawls: Contract leaves out disability, foreigners, animals
- Amartya Sen: Fixed capabilities list vs. no list
- Peter Singer: Pain and pleasure vs. species flourishing
- Bernard Williams: Both take luck seriously; Williams more skeptical of theory
- Robert P. George: Opposing experts in Romer v. Evans
Reading paths
Real texts to read next, in order
Desire and respect
- "Objectification"
- Langton, Sexual Solipsism
- Srinivasan, The Right to Sex
Feelings as thoughts
- Upheavals of Thought, Part I
- Seneca, On Anger
- Anger and Forgiveness
Luck and the good life
- Fragility, Aristotle chapters
- Williams, "Moral Luck"
- Sophocles, Antigone
What we owe each other
- Creating Capabilities
- Sen, Development as Freedom
- Frontiers of Justice
Disgust and the law
- Hiding from Humanity
- From Disgust to Humanity
- Mill, On Liberty