← All thinkers
Aristotle
ancient · Classical Greek, Peripatetic, virtue ethics
Talk with Clearing's Echo of Aristotle: an AI reconstruction built from Aristotle's published work. What is an Echo?
A good human life is an activity: using our distinctive capacities well, especially reason, over a whole life, with friends, in a community.
Questions to start with
What they hold
- Happiness (eudaimonia) is living and doing well — an activity of the soul in accordance with virtue over a complete life.
- Virtue is a settled state of character, learned by practice, that hits the mean between excess and deficiency.
- Practical wisdom (phronesis) is needed to see what the situation calls for; ethics can't be reduced to rules.
- Emotions can be right or wrong: feeling them at the right time, toward the right people, to the right degree is part of virtue.
- Humans are political animals; we flourish only in community and friendship.
- Some external goods and luck matter: great misfortune can mar a good person's happiness.
- Ethics is imprecise; seek only the precision the subject allows.
In the library
2,345 passages they can draw on and cite
- Metaphysicsc. 350 BCE430 passages
- Nicomachean Ethicsc. 340 BCE416 passages
- Politicsc. 350 BCE334 passages
- Physicsc. 350 BCE (translation by R. P. Hardie and R. K. Gaye, 1930)310 passages
- Topicsc. 350 BCE (translation: 1928)270 passages
- Rhetoricc. 350 BCE260 passages
- Posterior Analyticsc. 350 BCE (Mure translation, 1928)124 passages
- On the Soulc. 350 BCE59 passages
- Poeticsc. 335 BCE52 passages
- Categoriesc. 350 BCE52 passages
- On Interpretationc. 350 BCE34 passages
- Politics and Rhetoricc. 335 BCE4 passages
Debates
- “Anger is never justified.”with Seneca and Nussbaum
- “We should not grieve.”with Seneca and Nussbaum
- “A good person cannot be harmed.”with Socrates and Nussbaum
- “Happiness is up to us.”with Seneca and Beauvoir
- “Is knowing the good enough to do it?”with Socrates and Nussbaum · Virtue as knowledge vs. virtue as trained character
- “Should we act from feeling or from duty?”with Kant and Nussbaum · Virtuous character vs. duty from reason
- “Selfishness is a virtue.”with Nussbaum and Rand · Self-interest vs. compassion and capabilities as the ground of justice
- “Can a good life be lived only for oneself?”with Rand and Nussbaum · Both found ethics in human flourishing; Aristotle's is social and political
Reading paths
Real texts to read next, in order
The good life
- Nicomachean Ethics Book I
- Book II
- Book X
Getting angry well
- Nicomachean Ethics IV.5
- Seneca, On Anger
- Nussbaum, Anger and Forgiveness
Friendship
- Nicomachean Ethics VIII–IX
- Cicero, On Friendship
- Montaigne, "Of Friendship"